Cookie Refresh

Bigger sizes, softer cookies, and new designs. The only thing not changing? The price!

From the moment we switched up the bakery cases in the shops earlier this year, we knew the cookie lineup was the next thing to get some love.

And love on it, we did! Every cookie in our case is getting bigger, softer, more decorative, and all for the exact same price you’re currently paying.

Let’s take a closer look at each cookie and what to expect in its new, refreshed life!

Frosted Sugar

Our classic Sugar Cookies are now extra soft and fluffy! Designs will continue to change seasonally.

Pecan Thumbprint

Same recipe, more Pecan Thumbprint to love. The buttery shortbread cookie you love, packed with toasted pecans, with a generous swirl of buttercream frosting.


Your favorite peanut butter monster cookie grew a few sizes, but stayed just as delicious!

Vanilla Bean Confetti

The goal? An elevated grocery store style cookie, and this one knocked it outta the park! Our classic confetti cookie got larger and topped with buttercream + rainbow sprinkles.

Pumpkin Chocolate

Last but not least, we’re introducing a refreshed version of our Pumpkin Chocolate cookie just in time for Fall! It’s a vegan + wheat free treat for all to enjoy, with a drizzle of dark chocolate and flaky sea salt.

Each of these cookies can be found daily in the case. Add any as a side to your next Oven Baked Sandwich for just $.99! Watch for that seasonal cookie to switch up every few months, as well!

Can’t get enough? We’d love to make larger quantities for you! Check out our catering options here.